A person is holding a baking pan filled with stuffed red peppers in tomato sauce against a background of a wooden cutting board, table cloth, and plates.

How to Choose a Roasting Pan (Size, Material and Oven Fit)

So many people buy a roasting pan at the last minute for a family roast, then live with it for years, only using it sparingly and never discovering how much use they could get out of the right one.

A good roasting pan can do more than make an appearance at Christmas or Sunday lunch; if you choose the right size, material and fit for your oven from the start, you'll have a piece of cookware you can reach for year after year.

This guide covers what size to buy, which material suits how you cook, and how to check whether it fits your oven, rather than roasting recipes or times.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

  1. What Size Roasting Pan Do You Need?
  2. Which Material Is Best for a Roasting Pan?
  3. Will It Fit Your Oven?
  4. The Best Roasting Pan for You
  5. Frequently Asked Questions

What Size Roasting Pan Do You Need?

Size the pan to the roast plus a few centimetres of room on every side. When a roasting pan is too tight, the meat will steam in its own juices; when it's too big, the juices will spread thin and scorch before you can make gravy.

At Christmas, your roast often shares the pan with potatoes, pumpkin, and whatever else goes alongside it, so measure the whole spread, not just the meat. 

Bessemer's roasting pans come in three sizes:

  • Roaster 32cm (32 x 25 x 6cm): A roast chicken or small lamb roast for 2 to 4, or a tray of vegetables alongside a bigger roast.
  • Roaster 34cm  (34 x 24 x 12cm): Taller roasts, braises and slow cooks.
  • Roaster 40cm (40 x 34 x 8cm): The family roast or Christmas centrepiece, like a leg of lamb with vegetables around it.

A simple test to help with choosing the size of your roasting pan: lay the raw roast and its vegetables out on the bench in the footprint of the pan you're considering. If anything overlaps or touches the edges, go up a size. If there's much more than a few centimetres of space around everything, you've gone too big. A roasting dish with higher sides also helps with spatter.

“Family size roasting pans, lamb leg and vegies, best pans long lasting, easy clean, my last pan was used for 15 years, now my daughter is using that pan, I love my Bessemer” - Long-term customer, Jean B.

Which Material Is Best for a Roasting Pan?

There's no single best material for roasting pan cooking; it depends on whether you value easy release and lighter lifting, maximum browning for gravy, or something that goes straight to the table.

    Consider the weight of your roasting pan with a lid once it’s full. Can you lift it easily when it is full of hot fat at the end of a long cook, often with one hand under the roast and the other on the oven door? That's where lighter cast aluminium shines.

    Material

    Best for

    Trade-off

    Stainless steel

    Browning well and deglazing easily

    Food sticks without care, and the big sizes are heavy

    Enamelled cast iron

    Holding heat well

    Very heavy once loaded

    Glass and ceramic dishes

    Bakes and sides

    Not suited to stovetop gravy

    Thin pressed steel trays

    A cheap tray for occasional use

    Can warp at high heat

    Cast aluminium with non-stick

    Even heat, lighter lifting, easy release and clean-up

    Needs non-metal utensils and no harsh scourers

     

    Bessemer's roasters are constructed from cast aluminium with a heavy 5mm wall and a triple-layer non-stick fused with ceramic. They’re oven-safe to 220°C and, like the entire range, free of PFOA, lead and cadmium. This premium quality is what makes The Bessemer Difference.

    Will The Roasting Pan Fit Your Oven?

    Measure the inside of your oven, not the outside, and leave a few centimetres around the pan (handles included) so hot air can circulate. 

    Three quick checks will help you work out which size roasting pan you need:

    1. Width and depth - Compare your oven's internal width and depth with the pan's full footprint, handles included. A 40cm roaster measures 40 x 34cm before you add the handles.
    2. Rack height - Add the pan's depth to the height of your roast and check it clears the shelf above. A tall bird in a 12cm deep roaster should sit on a lower shelf.
    3. Stovetop gravy - Can you put a roasting pan on the stove? Only if it suits your cooktop. Many Bessemer roasting pans suit all cooktops, including induction.

    Consider the pan size for storage too. A 40cm pan needs a cupboard that fits it, so check your storage as well as your oven. 

    The Best Roasting Pan for You

    Smaller households cooking for one or two often get more from a multipan with the Universal Lid, which handles a small roast on the stovetop with oven-effect cooking. A casserole dish or Dutch oven is best suited for braises and slow cooks, and may see more use than a roasting pan in kitchens that mostly cook that way.

    If this is your first roaster and you're not sure it's worth adding yet, Upgrading Your Cookware explains when it earns its place.

    Every Bessemer roaster comes with a 25-year Lifetime Guarantee from the date of purchase, so you can buy with confidence, knowing it’s an investment piece you’ll treasure for years to come. Check out the full collection of roasting pans to get started.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is a non-stick roasting pan worth it?

    Yes, they release food easily, clean up fast, and let pan juices caramelise for gravy. The trade-off is you need to use non-metal utensils and clean gently.

    Do you need a rack in a roasting pan?

    Not always. A bed of thick-cut vegetables can lift your roast and flavour the juices, while a rack helps with fattier cuts where you want the fat to drain away.

    Can you make gravy in a roasting pan on the stove?

    Yes, if the pan suits your cooktop. On non-stick, scrape up the pan juices with a wooden spoon or silicone whisk, not metal.


    Back to blog